Centre collégial de développement de matériel didactique

General Public

INTRODUCTION

  • This form is designed to prepare you for the GAME PLAY.
  • Preview the FUND$ GAME material before beginning this Script Form.
  • Each Player is expected to complete a Script Form before the GAME PLAY.
  • You are not “in character” while filling out this form.
  • Much of the first half of the form should contain your own individual responses, with the obvious exception being the speech part.
  • Fill in the fields wherever you see the empty bullet symbol:
  • Your teacher may provide more specific directions as to which fields to complete and how.
  • To print the entire content of this script at once, please click on the PRINTER icon on this page.

 

What is your name?

  •  

What is the name of the other member of the General Public?

  •  

What is the assigned topic for the GAME?

  •  

Step 1

CHARACTER SKETCH

Sketch a character profile of a member of the General Public. Feel free to openly discuss your considerations with the other member of the General Public. You could opt to assume complementary roles or be altogether unique individuals.

What are the background characteristics of your character?

  1. Live: City/town of residence…?
  2. Occupation?
  3. Family status: single, with children, spouse, widowed…?
  4. Activities: political, leisure…?
  5. Education?

What do you want your character to look like? 

  1. Visible minority?
  2. Young, middle-aged, senior?
  3. Dressed casually, uniformed, formally attired, outfitted in a particular style?

Image

Roughly sketch or find an image of a character that best fits your character preferences. Place it in the box below.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What are some characteristics of speech that you would like to employ?

  1. Tone of voice: conversational, abrasive, respectful, candid, humorous, serious…?
  2. Vocabulary: formal, informal, colloquial?
  3. Accent or particular speech pattern?

Contrive a few anecdotal accounts relative to the topic and reflective of the character features you have defined. 

  1. What did your character just read about in the newspaper with regard to the assigned topic?
  2. What eventful thing recently happened to one of the character’s close friends that has a bearing on the topic?
  3. What does your character hear in the streets about research work on the topic?

Step 2

SIGNAL APPROVAL OF CODE OF CONDUCT

Review the Code of Conduct under the Rules and Code of Conduct and respond to the questions below.

Which part of the code of conduct do you think you will have no trouble adhering to?

Which part of the code of conduct do you think you may have some trouble adhering to? Why?

Step 3

HOW TO THINK NON-SCIENTIFICALLY

The best way to get into a non-scientific mindset is to read or watch some popular media sources of information and public opinion polls. Here are some navigational hints to help you find these sorts of information on the Internet.

Try to locate at least one source on the assigned topic in each of the following three areas:

  • A recent newspaper or popular magazine article
  • An “open electronic communication thread” such as online discussion forum or twitter feed
  • Public opinion poll results from existing websites (list provided below)

Copy and paste information and links directly into the relevant fields below.

Provide the following information for the recent newspaper or magazine article:

  1. Author(s):
  2. Article title:
  3. Publication title:
  4. Date:
  5. URL:
  6. After reading the article, briefly outline the popular view of the topic, research activities and government policies or actions.
  7. Provide the following information for the “open electronic communication thread”:

Extract three brief comments that are of relevance to the public’s views on the topic and place them in the table below:

OPEN ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATION TYPE (ONLINE FORUM, TWITTER FEED, FACEBOOK…) GIVEN USER IDENTITY/ONLINE NAME COMMENT
USE QUOTATION MARKS WHERE NEEDED
1.          
 
 
2.      
 
 
3.     
 
 

 

Find two online public opinion sites with public opinion facts on the assigned topic. Choose from this list:

  • Angus Reid Institute org
  • COMPAS INC.
  • CROP
  • Decima Research Inc.
  • Canadian Opinion Research Archive CORA
  • Ipsos-Reid Canada
  • Léger Marketing
  • POLLARA
  • Environics Research Group
  • PEW Research Group
  • Gallup
  • Eurostat
  • Eurobarometer
  • World Values Survey
  • OECD

What did you find?

NAME OF PUBLIC OPINION SITE & URL ARTICLE TITLE RELEVANT FACTS ON PUBLIC OPINION
  •  
  •  
  •   
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •   
  •  

Step 4

FRAME OPENING SPEECH

This speech, delivered in a few short minutes, should inform the Researchers and the Judges that the tax-paying public has its own share of concerns regarding the assigned topic. 
If you are not the only player for the General Public, be sure to work on this step together.

Before starting on your own speech, read the Sample Research Proposal to get a sense of what the research teams are presenting for the GAME PLAY. After reading it, copy and paste excerpts from the speech that exemplify scientific ways of thinking:

    • An excerpt exemplifying how scientists gather data
    • An excerpt where a research question is raised
    • An excerpt expressing a challenge to conventional wisdom on the topic

Read the Sample Opening Speech and then copy and paste excerpts from the speech that exemplify non-scientific ways of thinking:

    • An excerpt exemplifying a conversational style of communication
    • An excerpt exemplifying a non-scientific way of coming to a conclusion
    • An excerpt expressing the goal of “research” from the general public’s perspective

Opening Speech Template

THE FOUR PILLARS QUESTIONS YOUR ANSWERS
(RESPOND AS IF YOU WERE DELIVERING THE ANSWERS FOR A SPEECH)
A. INTRODUCTION
(Start by borrowing material from your STEP 1 - CHARACTER SKETCH.)
  1. Who are you? Why are you here? Who asked you to speak?
  2. What basic interests do you, as a representative of the general public, have in research on the assigned topic?
 
B. MAJOR CONCERNS
  1. What major concerns does the general public have with regard to the topic? How do you know this? Where did you obtain this information?
  2. What are some specific examples of these concerns?
 
C. RECOMMENDATIONS
  1. How does the general public want social science researchers to address these problems?
  2. Why do problems persist in spite of years of research?
  3. How should the research funds be spent? What should be the priorities?
 
D. CLOSING REMARKS
  1. Why should Researchers listen to the General Public?
  2. What do you hope to see in the upcoming research proposals?
 

 

Step 5

JUDGING JUDGES

  1. Add the Judges’ criteria to the numbered items in the first column once they have made them available.
  2. Individually place a check mark in the box that best describes your (the General Public’s) degree of agreement with each of the criteria.

    CRITERIA NONE AT ALL VERY LIMITED MODERATE HIGH VERY HIGH
    1.          
    2.          
    3.          

     

  3. To be better prepared to react to the Judges’ funding decisions during the GAME PLAY, identify two specific areas where you and the Judges definitely do not concur in terms of the judging criteria (briefly explain):
    •  

Step 6

PRACTISE OPENING SPEECH

Practise running through the speech with the other member of the General Public or a fellow student and fill out the CHECKLIST below.

  • Adequate statement of concerns on the topic.
  • Coherent representation of General Public position.
  • Clear distinction between “us” (non-scientists) and “them” (scientists).
  • Sufficient examples to back up the more general points.
  • Adequate justification for General Public’s recommendations for future research.
  • Character personification provides authenticity to speech.
  • Convincing communication style.
  • Delivered in a few minutes.

Identify two areas of the speech that need improvement :

  •  

Step 7

deliver SPEECH

  • Make the opening speech during game play as per specifications provided by your teacher.

Step 8

QUESTION FUNDS ALLOCATION

  • After judges announce their funding decisions, provide a brief explanation to all assembled of how you, the general public, view these decisions. Where do you agree and disagree?

Step 9

Write reflection

Step 10

SUBMIT ASSIGNMENT MATERIAL

  • Complete the required post-game work and submit as per teacher instructions.

General Public Sample Materials

SAMPLE GENERAL PUBLIC OPENING SPEECH

Topic: Sustainable Development
General Public: Megan Strett from Nova Scotia
Speech: Delivered in a conversational manner at beginning of the GAME PLAY

INTRODUCTION

Hello distinguished judges and researchers. My name is Megan Strett and I hail from a small town in Nova Scotia. I am a retired bank teller and mother of three and grandmother of five.

I am here at the invitation of the Research Council judges. The judges wanted me to act as a representative of the general public. I will do my best to provide you all with some sense of what the general public may think about the topic of sustainable development. I reckon that means you all expect me to show you how ordinary citizens want the research money spent. That money comes from our tax money. The hope is the judges will make some sound and responsible decisions as to how that tax money should be spent. 

You may be wondering what I do that qualifies me to talk about sustainable development. Well, for the last few years I’ve been involved in a local environmental group. I am now the official spokesperson. We are concerned about ocean pollutants and over-fishing off our Atlantic coast. I actually did some homework for a Press Release for our group this week. According to a 2003 Environics poll, 62% of Atlantic Canadians feel greater responsibility should be given to stakeholders in the management, protection, and sustainable use of fisheries and marine resources. Regular folk like us feel left out of the equation, pure and simple!

From where I sit, government folks wheel and deal with other big wheels in large corporations and other government agencies; they rub elbows with each other at black tie events, travelling across large land masses and seas without ever really seeing and touching the real world. They are so far removed from the streets and the streams. The little people like me are intimately involved in our neighbourhood ecosystems. We cannot afford private jets or fancy cocktail gowns. 

Hopefully, researchers can find more effective ways to make decisions about the fisheries problems.

MAJOR CONCERNS

A little closer to home, my cousins in Nova Scotia wanted me to tell you of their worries: farm-raised fish companies on or near our coastal waters and sky-rocketing fuel prices.

Frankenfish or “mad fish disease” worries many in my family as there have been mega-fish farms set up all along our coast. As noted by a Fisheries & Oceans Canada study in 2005, “aquaculture issues, such as farming operations, escaped fish, diseased fish, pollution, genetic contamination, capacity” are all of concern to many in the general public living in coastal areas around the country. Our people in Halifax were seen as having the most serious reservations about the sustainability of these new fishing operations. An example of this is my brother Bob catching this ugly creature of a fish. It looked like a skinned rabbit with gills and a beaver tail. Bob says mad scientists are receiving research money by our government to scramble DNA and mess with the natural order of things. Why? God help us!

Gas prices have increased dramatically over the past three years and yet nothing is being done to lessen our dependence on fossil fuel sources for energy. Some serious re-thinking is required. Researchers need to find ways to put the consumers in the driver’s seat. Why not support more organizations like GasBuddy to let the public know the cheapest location to pump up? Let the researchers find ways to undercut the power of giant corporations and petro gangsterism.

It is as if the companies do not care enough about us, the consumers, who are paying such high prices. Corporations are making record profits yet the environment and regular people like me only suffer and lose. This is not sustainable economic development. Regular people are stunted in their development, like the environment which we all depend on for the air we breathe and the water we drink.

RECOMMENDATIONS

Do not accept research funding from these big corporations, as their needs are too well-researched and the regular folk end up suffering. I watch Michael Moore documentaries so I know about how decisions are actually made. 

We really need researchers to investigate the high cost of living and the lack of sustainable energy sources for our environment. What are our governments doing to help us? Obviously, not enough. Why is corporate greed so prevalent? Why does economic growth trump sustainable fisheries and affordable fuel sources?

Therefore, I plead for you, as highly capable investigators, to find solutions, viable solutions, ones that normal people can benefit from and feel the effects of in the near future.

CLOSING REMARKS

Regular folks hear very little about what you do as researchers. I can only hope that your priorities are our priorities; that you can keep corporate greed at bay and find ways to help the little people…please put your investigative skills to practical use. 

I thank you, judges, for taking the trouble to include me in these proceedings and hope that I have helped to put a more public face on the problem of sustainable development.

Thank you!