The Research Competition
As members of an Ethics Board, the Reviewers are expected to enforce the ethical standards of research in the Contestant Research Proposals and ensure fair and equitable procedures are followed in the Contest proceedings.
An online tutorial on research ethics helps the Reviewers to evaluate the Research Proposals and judge the Contest participants’ adherence to their Code of Conduct.
The Reviewers determine whether to endorse the short-listed proposals for a second reading and write a Final Report on the Contest.
When the Lead Research Director convenes the first meeting of Reviewers, you should:
The Reviewers should use this form, or a modified version of it, to evaluate the short-listed Research Proposals. Use a separate form for each evaluation. Items 6-16 apply only to Research Proposals involving direct contact with participants. Place a checkmark in the N/A boxes for these items for proposals that do not involve direct contact with participants.
Reviewer Name: ____________________________________
Code # ______________________ Short title of Proposal ________________________________________________________
| EVALUATION CRITERIA | PLACE A CHECKMARK IN APPROPRIATE BOX | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| YES | SOMEWHAT | NO | N/A | ||
| 1. | Does the Contestant appear to have properly credited all sources referred to and provided a complete bibliography of sources? | ||||
| 2. | Are the information sources or intended data sources from reputable sources or has the Contestant at least stated the limitations of any less reputable sources? | ||||
| 3. | Does the research question warrant the time and trouble to pursue the research? | ||||
| 4. | Does the Contestant demonstrate a clear and thoughtful understanding of the ethical rules governing research? | ||||
| 5. | Would you feel comfortable giving the Contestant permission to gather data in this way? | ||||
| 6. | Does the data collection plan appear to involve dignified, fair and respectful treatment of individuals or groups? | ||||
| 7. | Would you characterize the proposed interaction with the research subjects as LOW RISK? 1 | ||||
| 8. | Does the recruitment (sampling) plan provide enough detail to judge whether it is ethical? | ||||
| 9. | Does the proposal exclude participants who are legally (under 18) or otherwise unable to give valid consent (e.g., people with learning difficulties, receiving counselling or suicidal…) or in a dependent or subordinate relationship with the researcher? | ||||
| 10. | Does the recruitment (sampling) plan restrict the participants to people who can safely be studied by untrained, novice student researchers? | ||||
| 11. | Is adequate information provided in the consent/permission form concerning participant rights, such as the right to withdraw? | ||||
| 12. | Are adequate measures in place to obtain informed/voluntary consent? | ||||
| 13. | Will the participants be aware they are being studied? | ||||
| 14. | Are adequate measures in place to ensure confidentiality? | ||||
| 15. | Are the risks to the participants’ health, safety or professional integrity acceptable? | ||||
| 16. | Would you be willing to participate? | ||||
| COMMENTS | |
|---|---|
|
|
“NO” responses warrant serious consideration. Consult the Tri-Council Policy Statement TCPS used in Step 1 of the Step-by-Step for further information. You may also want to confer with your fellow Reviewers.
After completing the 16-item checklist items, rate the proposal under review:
Please forward these completed forms to the Judges’ Communications Officer and the Lead Research Director. Only the Judges’ Communications Officer and the Lead Research Director will have access to these forms.
1 Low risk is defined as involving minimal to no physical or emotional risk to either the Contestants or the research participants, risks that are no greater than those likely to be encountered in everyday life. A proposal that involves significant risk or involvement or direct knowledge of illegal activities should be rejected. Tests that determine IQ or emotional or mental well-being or those requiring the extraction of bodily substances or fluids, the use of drugs (including alcohol), the consumption of caffeinated drinks or special diets can pose significant physical or emotional risks and do not qualify as low risk.
Ethics Board Reviewers ensure that finalists’ Research Proposals are thoroughly vetted for compliance with ethical standards. Ethics Board Reviewers agree to:
The Contestants agree to:
- Conduct their research in a way that honours accuracy and truth and formally recognizes the academic contributions of others.
- Scientific fraud, forgery, fabrication of information and misconduct are not condoned at any level. This involves:
- Referring to sources from which they have extracted central ideas, theories, findings, specific arguments, definitions, conclusions, interpretations and scales of measurement, even when not using direct quotations.
- Avoiding fabrication of facts and figures, falsification by wrongful author attribution or exaggeration and plagiarism.
- Avoiding colloquial, emotional and non-academic expression.
- Consistently and correctly using a formatting style that is appropriate to the discipline(s) featured in the proposal.
- Obey the general rules regarding the ethical treatment of human subjects, which are embodied in the ethical rules governing researchers and members of your institution’s community.
- This mostly involves:
- Informed consent, which may include a consent form (attached as an appendix item for the Contest) or, when only verbal consent is viable, a consent script (embodied in the Method Plan).
- For subjects under 18 years of age, informed consent from a parent or legal guardian.Recognition of the subjects’ right:
- Not to be distressed, humiliated, dishonoured or harmed through their participation
- To withdraw from study at any point in time
- Requesting permission from the director, board of directors, manager, owner, or other person in charge for access to institutions.
- Permission form to request access to and terms of use for personal possessions such as photos, personal diaries or letters.
- Refraining from direct contact with children and physically, emotionally or socio-economically vulnerable individuals.
Protect themselves and others from physical, emotional, legal, social or professional harm.
This mostly involves erring on the side of caution. It is best to exclude a technique if the related liability or potential for harm is unclear.
I, _________________________________ ,
Signature: __________________________________
Date of signature: ______________________________
EBR Applicant’s Name:
College Name:
Status:
Position/Program/Department:
If you are a teacher, are you sponsoring a Contest applicant?
Email address:
Phone #:
Please also include a STATEMENT OF INTENT (100-word account of reason for applying).