Sample Funding Criteria
| CRITERIA | PERFORMANCE INDICATORS |
|---|---|
| 1. Well-organized & prepared |
|
| 2. Positive repercussions on society |
|
| 3. Cost-effectiveness |
|
Sample Score Sheets
EVALUATION GRID
Discipline: _________________
| CRITERIA | 1-3 | 4-7 | 8-10 | SCORE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Sound, Logical Proposal |
Proposal is vague and unclear; lacks grounding in research field; limited reference to scientific terms or data gathering or sampling plan; may not be ethical (probably too vague to determine). | Proposal makes some sense and is fairly logical in sequence; some connection to existing research in the discipline; weak/limited choice of methods for gathering data, selecting sample and analyzing data; limited use of scientific terminology; could be ethical. | Proposal is very clear and makes lots of sense; grounded in existing research in the discipline; excellent choice of methods for gathering data, selecting sample and analyzing data; sophisticated use of scientific terminology; ethically sound. | |
| 2. High Impact Potential |
Little to no evidence provided of the value of investing in this research; unclear or vague path to impact in the field. | Some support for research leading to breakthroughs; evidence of some potential for making improvements; some justification for investing in this research project. | Convincing case for research leading to major breakthroughs; demonstrated potential for research to contribute to improvements; justified value of investing in this research project. | |
| 3. Professionalism | Researchers lacked professionalism in some ways: Weak team work, disorganized presentation, potentially unethical plans or work processes, lack of accountability for monies and materials required. |
Researchers demonstrated some professionalism: worked together, presented in an organized fashion, adhered to ethical rules of conduct, costed and planned work with some degree of accountability. | Researchers demonstrated professionalism: worked well together presented in a highly organized fashion, adhered to ethical rules of conduct, costed and planned work in a detailed and accountable manner. | |
| TOTAL SCORE |
||||
| Comments | ||||
TALLY SHEET
| DISCIPLINE | CRITERION 1 1-10 |
CRITERION 2 1-10 |
CRITERION 3 1-10 |
SCORE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Anthropology | ||||
| 2. Business | ||||
| 3. Economics | ||||
| 4. Geography | ||||
| 5. History | ||||
| 6. Philosophy | ||||
| 7. Political Science | ||||
| 8. Psychology | ||||
| 9. Religious Studies | ||||
| 10. Sociology |
Decision Sheet Template
To show funding distribution choices of Judges and General Public. $1,000,000 in research funds to be distributed
| SOCIAL SCIENCE DISCIPLINES | RESEARCH COUNCIL $ GRANTS | GENERAL PUBLIC $ GRANT OPINION |
|---|---|---|
| Anthropology | ||
| Business | ||
| Economics | ||
| Geography | ||
| History/Classics | ||
| Philosophy | ||
| Political Science | ||
| Psychology | ||
| Religious Studies | ||
| Sociology |
GAME PLAY Agenda and Set Design
The judges are in charge of chairing the GAME PLAY. This is the recommended agenda. The total time for the in-class competition is 2-2.5 hours.
AGENDA
| STEP | WHAT THE JUDGES NEED TO DO | TIME IN MINUTES |
|---|---|---|
Set-up
|
~15-20 | |
| 1. Welcome |
|
~5 |
| 2. General Public Speech |
|
~5 |
| 3. Discipline Group Presentations |
|
~60 |
| 4. Judges’ Deliberations |
|
~15 |
| 5. Announcement of Funding Winners |
|
~10 |
| 6. Question & Answer Period |
|
~10 |
| 7. Adjourn |
|
Set design: Configure classroom seating by role grouping:
- Set up equipment and place materials such as placards, score sheets, gavel, timer …
- Provide sufficient space for discipline teams to present and move as per your requirements.
- The teacher has templates for name placards and funding currency.
- A gavel may be hard to come by, so be inventive and bring an improvised device, hopefully nothing that will damage furniture or promote hearing loss.
CLASSROOM CONFIGURATION MAP

