Judge Sample Materials

 Sample Funding Criteria

CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS
1. Well-organized & prepared
  • Presented in an orderly, thoughtful way
  • Consistently followed through on key elements
  • Appeared confident they knew what they were talking about
2. Positive repercussions on society
  • Recognizable account of projected value of the research
  • Convincing justification for social impact
3. Cost-effectiveness
  • Evidence they factored reduced costs into the design
  • Careful detailing of costs in budget
  • Demonstrated strong management skills and abilities

 

Sample Score Sheets 

EVALUATION GRID

Discipline: _________________

CRITERIA 1-3 4-7 8-10 SCORE
1. Sound, Logical 
Proposal
Proposal is vague and unclear; lacks grounding in research field; limited reference to scientific terms or data gathering or sampling plan; may not be ethical (probably too vague to determine). Proposal makes some sense and is fairly logical in sequence; some connection to existing research in the discipline; weak/limited choice of methods for gathering data, selecting sample and analyzing data; limited use of scientific terminology; could be ethical. Proposal is very clear and makes lots of sense; grounded in existing research in the discipline; excellent choice of methods for gathering data, selecting sample and analyzing data; sophisticated use of scientific terminology; ethically sound.  
2. High Impact 
Potential
Little to no evidence provided of the value of investing in this research; unclear or vague path to impact in the field. Some support for research leading to breakthroughs; evidence of some potential for making improvements; some justification for investing in this research project. Convincing case for research leading to major breakthroughs; demonstrated potential for research to contribute to improvements; justified value of investing in this research project.  
3. Professionalism Researchers lacked professionalism in some ways: 
Weak team work, disorganized presentation, potentially unethical plans or work processes, lack of accountability for monies and materials required.
Researchers demonstrated some professionalism: worked together, presented in an organized fashion, adhered to ethical rules of conduct, costed and planned work with some degree of accountability. Researchers demonstrated professionalism: worked well together presented in a highly organized fashion, adhered to ethical rules of conduct, costed and planned work in a detailed and accountable manner.  
TOTAL
SCORE
Comments

 

TALLY SHEET

DISCIPLINE CRITERION 1
1-10
CRITERION 2
1-10
CRITERION 3
1-10
SCORE
1. Anthropology        
2. Business        
3. Economics        
4. Geography        
5. History        
6. Philosophy        
7. Political Science        
8. Psychology        
9. Religious Studies        
10. Sociology        

 

Decision Sheet Template

To show funding distribution choices of Judges and General Public. $1,000,000 in research funds to be distributed

SOCIAL SCIENCE DISCIPLINES RESEARCH COUNCIL $ GRANTS GENERAL PUBLIC $ GRANT OPINION
Anthropology    
Business    
Economics    
Geography    
History/Classics    
Philosophy    
Political Science    
Psychology    
Religious Studies    
Sociology    

 

GAME PLAY Agenda and Set Design

The judges are in charge of chairing the GAME PLAY. This is the recommended agenda. The total time for the in-class competition is 2-2.5 hours.

AGENDA

STEP WHAT THE JUDGES NEED TO DO TIME IN MINUTES
  Set-up
  • Arrange seating & materials (i.e., team name placards)
  • Install equipment if/where necessary (i.e., online stopwatch or projection of criteria or other such information)
  • Give everyone some time to organize their materials
~15-20
1. Welcome
  • Call the funding competition meeting to order
  • Greet everyone and thank them for attending
  • Briefly review agenda & time frame
  • Explain protocol (presentation order & placement, speaking time regulations, break…)
~5
2. General Public Speech
  • Invite the general public to make a 2-3 minute speech
  • Thank the general public once complete
~5
3. Discipline Group Presentations
  • Invite and thank each group in turn (keep momentum going)
  • Allow ~5 minutes per presentation
~60
4. Judges’ Deliberations
  • Call a 15-minute break for everyone except yourselves
  • Determine allocation of funding
  • Ask everyone to leave the room for the designated time for privacy and quiet
~15
5. Announcement of Funding Winners
  • Present your funding decisions
  • Justify your funding allocation decisions
~10
6. Question & Answer Period
  • Hold a Q & A period
  • Specifically call on Journalists and General Public to pose some questions
~10
7. Adjourn
  • Ask for motion to adjourn the meeting
  • Thank everyone
 

 

Set design: Configure classroom seating by role grouping:

  • Set up equipment and place materials such as placards, score sheets, gavel, timer …
  • Provide sufficient space for discipline teams to present and move as per your requirements.
  • The teacher has templates for name placards and funding currency.
  • A gavel may be hard to come by, so be inventive and bring an improvised device, hopefully nothing that will damage furniture or promote hearing loss.

 

CLASSROOM CONFIGURATION MAP

Classroom Configuration Map